Social Conservatism is Going Out the Door

Michelle Fields, the Daily Caller’s star reporter and a frequent contributor to Fox News, has a great blog post on what is happening to the GOP, and where it is going:
The biggest threat to conservatives right now is President Barack Obama, but the long-term threat to conservatism is an internal threat– young republicans. The RNC is doing everything in its power to prevent them from gaining power, but will it work?
If you were to talk to any reporter covering this year’s election they’ll tell you that most of the attendees at GOP events are over 40 years old. You can’t help but ask yourself “where are the young people?” Well, they’re organizing a libertarian take-over.
Young republicans aren’t on board with social conservatism, instead we’re seeing an unprecedented level of enthusiasm for libertarianism. Many of my conservative colleagues will argue that, “ah, this is just a phase amongst young republicans.” But being socially liberal isn’t a phase. What we’re seeing is a cultural shift that is inevitably going to force the Republican Party to make some major adjustments. For example, take gay marriage— Millennials have grown up a time where it’s no longer taboo to be openly gay. Our favorite films and television shows have gay characters. Some of the most prominent figures in American culture are openly gay. And if you look at the polls, public opinion has moved sharply in favor of gay marriage in recent years with 76% of 18-34 year olds saying that the law should recognize same sex marriage.
The core message, evident by the title, is that social conservatism is going out the door. The younger generation has never liked any of it, and they never will. It is solely the purview of a dying demographic, which bizarrely the Republican Party is trying desperately to latch on to.
I’ve written previously about social conservatism in the GOP, and I stand by it. Social conservatism will be the death of the Republican party if they don’t change ASAP. The country is very rapidly turning away from those positions—aside from the pro-life stance—and in a generation there won’t be anyone who votes the way the Republicans are thinking.
Now considering that the party is reliant on popular support, where do you think it will be?
I don’t care about how much corruption there is and how much power the party has. If it is totally out of sync with the public on half of the major issues of the day, it will not last. Period. The party needs to recognize that today, or it will be utterly irrelevant in twenty years, maybe less. Santorum’s campaign was not the rise of the social conservatives—indeed, it was the last gasp, the last hurrah of a movement that desperately wanted to make itself important. But they are so out of touch, their attempt was comical. I mean, just look at Todd Akin.
Hopefully, if Romney wins in November, he will drop the pretensions of being even a mild social conservative, send a message to the Republican base, and let it discard the insanity that has plagued it as of late. Otherwise, we may end up being a one-party state in just a generation.
United Liberty








Good post, but the same could be said about the Democratic Party and socialist economics. If the Democratic Party were to drop the Obama/Elizabeth Warren wing, they would pick up a huge slice of the independent vote, just as the Republican Party would if they were to jettison the Santorum/Bachmann faction. The question going forward really is, which party will dump their toxic extremist faction in order to win the centrist vote? And I would imagine that to be whichever one loses this election.
That is a very insightful comment, good sir. I do believe, however, there will be more resistance for the Democrats to jettison their socialist economics because everyone wants free stuff. What I think I would see from the Dems instead is certain constituencies being abandoned—in particular, labor unions. In fact, if Obama loses this year, I would not be surprised if the Dems completely ignore (if not demonize) labor unions in 2014, especially public sector ones.
If the GOP loses this election, they won’t kick the Santorum wing out. Why? Because Santorum lost in the primary to the rather muddled Romney, and everyone in the party will be saying “We should have nominated a REAL conservative!” (I.e., Santorum.) If Romney wins, though, we might see the Santorum wing tempered a bit. Maybe.
I’m not sure the Democratic Party will ever abandon or turn against labor unions, given their financial clout. But some prominent Democratic executives in deep blue states, notably Andrew Cuomo in New York and Rahm Emannuel in Chicago, have pushed back against labor unions. The influence of unions is clearly waning, as was proven in Wisconsin.
But I could easily envision the Democratic Party platform turning back towards the Clinton, centrist model if they lose this election. Obama has essentially brought the Democrats back to the Carter years, which were certainly a dark time for them that led to considerable time in the wilderness politically.
I fear you may be correct that the social conservatives would couch a loss in language about Romney not being conservative enough. Few lessons seemed to be learned from Santorum’s last Senate race.
RT. i suspect you are right. although i would measure the democrat extremist a bit less extreme than the republican extremist. ( i dont see the democrats as that much socialist as i see the republicans as dogmatically religious. some suggest that those who desire to keep fire departments are continuing to support a socialist program. so maybe its all relative.
Thanks for the article. As a teen Libertarian in public office I’ve seen this phenomenon.
For info on people using voluntary Libertarian tools on similar and other issues, please see the non-partisan Libertarian International Organization @ http://www.Libertarian-International.org ….
Abortion, the death penalty, homosexual marriage, all these hot-button social issues should be decided by the individual states through the power of the 10th Amendment.
Let Federalism work.
Post new comment